Open Farm Dog Food Review (2026): Is Humanely Raised Pet Food Worth $94/Month?
A detailed Open Farm dog food review covering ingredient quality, sourcing transparency, protein options, and whether the premium over conventional kibble is justified.
This post may contain affiliate links. We earn a small commission on purchases at no cost to you. Learn more.
Pet food is the category where sustainable choices have the highest environmental leverage — and the highest greenwash risk. “Natural,” “premium,” and “holistic” on pet food labels mean exactly nothing by regulation. Open Farm is one of the few brands in the premium category that backs its claims with verifiable third-party certification. Here’s what actually makes it different, and an honest look at whether the price is justified.
What Open Farm Is
Open Farm is a Canadian pet food company (now distributed widely in the U.S.) that launched in 2014 with one differentiating principle: every protein source would be humanely raised and traceable. They’ve built their entire product line around that principle and backed it with third-party certification from the Global Animal Partnership (GAP) — the same welfare standard Whole Foods uses for their meat.
The brand makes dry kibble, wet food, freeze-dried raw, and raw-coated kibble across multiple protein sources: chicken, turkey, salmon, beef, pork, and lamb. They also have a dedicated cat food line. All formulas are non-GMO verified.
Sourcing: The Actual Differentiator
Every bag of Open Farm has a traceable lot code. Enter it at their website. You’ll get a direct link to the farms that supplied the protein in that specific production lot, along with the welfare certification level applied.
Global Animal Partnership (GAP) uses a five-step ladder:
- Step 1: No crates, no cages, no crowding
- Step 2: Enriched environment
- Step 3: Enhanced outdoor access
- Step 4: Pasture-raised
- Step 5: Animal-centered, with full day outdoors
- Step 5+: Slaughtered on farm (no transport stress)
Open Farm sources at GAP Step 2+ for most of their poultry, meaning the animals have enriched environments and enhanced access above baseline welfare standards. The salmon recipes use Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) certified wild-caught Pacific salmon.
This is not marketing copy. GAP does third-party on-farm audits. The certification is real.
Compare this to brands like Merrick “Real Texas Beef & Sweet Potato” — the word “real” is unregulated, the beef sourcing is undisclosed, and there’s no farm traceability. That’s the standard the premium pet food industry operates at. Open Farm is the exception.
Ingredient Quality: The Homestead Turkey & Chicken Formula
The 22 lb Homestead Turkey & Chicken is their flagship dry food. Ingredient list, first ten ingredients:
- Deboned turkey (first-listed, the primary protein)
- Chicken
- Turkey meal (concentrated protein — appropriate as a secondary protein ingredient)
- Sweet potato
- Lentils
- Chickpeas
- Peas
- Canola oil
- Pea flour
- Natural chicken flavor
What’s absent: corn syrup, wheat middlings, soy protein isolate, BHA, BHT, ethoxyquin, artificial colors, artificial flavors. Those absences matter — BHA and BHT are petroleum-derived antioxidants used as preservatives in many conventional kibbles; they’re classified as possible carcinogens by the International Agency for Research on Cancer.
The Omega-6 to Omega-3 ratio in this formula is approximately 5:1, which is reasonable for a kibble. (Raw food advocates will point out that processed kibble, regardless of ingredient quality, delivers degraded Omega-3s relative to fresh food. That’s true. It’s a limitation of the format, not specific to Open Farm.)
Protein Content and Feeding Rates
The Homestead Turkey & Chicken formula is 30% crude protein and 15% crude fat — above average for kibble, appropriate for active adult dogs. For a 50-lb active dog, recommended feeding is approximately 2.5 cups/day. The 22 lb bag contains roughly 88 cups, which works out to 35 days of supply at that rate.
At $94 for 35 days: $2.69/day. At $94 for a more sedentary dog eating 1.75 cups/day: $1.88/day.
How does that compare?
- Purina Pro Plan Chicken & Rice (32 lb / $72): approximately $0.90/day for a 50-lb dog
- Hill’s Science Diet (35 lb / $85): approximately $0.97/day
- Merrick Grain-Free (22 lb / $78): approximately $1.56/day
- Open Farm ($94): approximately $1.88–2.69/day depending on activity level
The premium over Hill’s or Purina is roughly double. The premium over Merrick is about 20–70% depending on your dog’s size.
The Grain-Free Debate
A brief note: the FDA investigated a potential link between grain-free diets (including many premium brands) and dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in dogs from 2018–2023. The investigation is ongoing; causality has not been proven and the FDA did not issue a formal recommendation against grain-free food. Open Farm has grain-free recipes and grain-inclusive recipes. If your vet has concerns about grain-free feeding given your dog’s breed and cardiac history, stick to grain-inclusive formulas.
The Wet Food and Freeze-Dried Lines
Open Farm’s wet food avoids carrageenan — a common wet food thickener linked in some studies to intestinal inflammation. The Harvest Chicken recipe uses pumpkin and butternut squash as binders instead. For dogs with digestive sensitivities or who need higher moisture intake (senior dogs, kidney function concerns), this is the best sustainable wet food available in 2026.
The freeze-dried line is their premium tier. Freeze-drying preserves the nutrient profile of raw food without the bacterial risk of raw feeding. At $42 for 13.5 oz, it’s intended as a topper (a handful over kibble) rather than a standalone food for most dogs. For picky eaters that refuse kibble, adding freeze-dried topper often resolves the problem without fully committing to raw feeding.
Where to Buy
Amazon: Available on Subscribe & Save, which gives 5–15% off. The auto-ship removes the “running out of food” problem. Prime shipping handles the bulk weight without a premium.
Open Farm’s website: Occasionally runs promotions, including introductory offers for first-time customers. The direct purchase also means more margin goes to the brand rather than the retailer, which matters for a brand building on sustainability.
Chewy: Another major retailer. Chewy’s Autoship program is competitive with Amazon Subscribe & Save. Price is usually within $2–3 of Amazon.
Local pet stores: Many independent pet retailers carry Open Farm. Buying local keeps margin in your community.
Honest Limitations
Open Farm isn’t perfect. A few things worth noting:
The pea/legume question: Like many grain-free kibbles, Open Farm uses peas, lentils, and chickpeas as carbohydrate sources. These ingredients are at the center of the DCM investigation mentioned above. Open Farm has responded by offering grain-inclusive formulas as an alternative. If your vet is watching your dog’s cardiac health, discuss before choosing the grain-free recipes.
The kibble processing reality: No matter how high-quality the ingredients, extrusion (the high-heat, high-pressure process that makes kibble) degrades some nutrients. Open Farm’s finished product is better than conventional kibble because it starts with better ingredients, but it’s not nutritionally equivalent to fresh or raw food. If budget allows, their freeze-dried topper bridges part of that gap.
Price: $94 for a 22 lb bag is real money, especially for large-breed dogs that go through food quickly. A 90-lb dog eating 3+ cups/day might need a new bag every 3.5–4 weeks, which is $25–30/month more than comparable non-humane-certified options. For some households, that’s not possible.
Verdict
Open Farm is the benchmark sustainable dry dog food in 2026. The GAP sourcing certification is real, the traceability is functional (not performative), the ingredient list is clean, and the brand has a consistent recall record. The price premium is meaningful and not everyone can absorb it.
If you’re transitioning from conventional kibble: start with the Homestead Turkey & Chicken 22 lb bag on Subscribe & Save. Transition slowly (25%/75% for 3 days, then 50/50, then 75/25, then full switch). Most dogs handle the transition well because the simpler ingredient list is easier to digest than highly processed conventional food.
If budget is the constraint: Open Farm’s 4.5 lb bags allow you to use it as a partial replacement or topper rather than a full-diet switch. Some sustainable impact at lower total cost.
Our Top Picks
Open Farm Homestead Turkey & Chicken Dry Dog Food (22 lb)
The flagship dry food. GAP-certified poultry, non-GMO vegetables, no synthetic preservatives. Ingredient list reads cleanly. 22 lb bag lasts a 55-lb dog about 6 weeks — roughly $1.70/day. The sourcing transparency alone puts it in a different category from most premium kibble.
Open Farm Wild-Caught Salmon Dry Dog Food (22 lb)
Wild-caught Pacific salmon as the first ingredient, MSC certified. For dogs that do better on fish protein, this is the sustainable option. Slightly higher price than the poultry formulas reflects the fish sourcing premium. Omega-3 content is genuinely high for a kibble.
Open Farm Harvest Chicken Wet Dog Food (12.5 oz, 12-pack)
Single-source chicken, pumpkin, butternut squash, chickpeas. No carrageenan (a common wet food additive linked to inflammation). For dogs needing higher moisture intake (kidney health, senior dogs, fussy drinkers) this is the best wet food option in the sustainable category.
Open Farm Freeze-Dried Raw Dog Food (13.5 oz)
The premium tier. Use as a topper over kibble (add a handful per meal) or feed as a standalone for smaller dogs. Freeze-drying preserves nutrients without high heat processing. The sourcing is the same as their kibble — the format is just different. For picky eaters, this works when nothing else does.